New ETFs Need a Sharp Selloff Test
Whether newly listed ETFs are worth buying has become a topic of interest for many investors. A netizen posted on Dcard titled "Should You Buy a New ETF? See Whether It Has Been Through a Sharp Selloff," arguing that a new ETF must go through a major market correction before its defensive performance can be further assessed, using the actively managed Fuh Hwa Financial Dividend ETF (00998A), listed in April this year, as an example to analyze its performance during the October pullback, sparking discussion.
October Pullback Was First Major Market Test
The original poster said 00998A was only listed in April this year, so the October pullback was arguably the first major market test since its listing. From October 6 to 16, the TAIEX fell 5.44%, while Yuanta Taiwan 50 (0050) fell 6.44% on a total-return basis. In contrast, 00998A edged down only 0.74% over the same period, showing relatively resilient performance and therefore attracting market attention.
One Resilient Episode Does Not Prove Long-Term Stability
However, the original poster also argued that performance in a single market correction is not enough to judge whether an ETF has long-term defensive ability. If financial stocks themselves correct in the future, or factors such as rapid interest-rate changes weigh on the market, 00998A could still face volatility, and investors should not conclude from one pullback-period return that it can stay stable in all market environments.
Use as a Supplement, Avoid Over-Concentration
The original poster said 00998A can be treated as part of an asset allocation, but should not be viewed as a safe haven, nor should investors concentrate too much capital in a single product. The poster also asked other netizens for their views on new ETFs. Many respondents said the key to picking ETFs remains the holdings and stock-selection logic, stressing that knowing what product you are buying is the priority. Some suggested using technology stocks as core holdings and financial stocks as satellite holdings to diversify the risk of a sharp market selloff. Other netizens were upbeat on 00998A's defensive showing, while some said financial products offer a different allocation choice when technology-stock positioning is crowded, and others said they would consider it after it has been through one market test.